Hall Render represented Catholic Health Initiatives Colorado (“CHIC”) in defending a lawsuit, Peddada v. Catholic Health Initiatives Colorado, et al., No. 23-cv-01921-NYW-MDB, 2026 WL 2754082 (D. Colo. 2026), brought by Dr. Peddada, a highly compensated radiation oncologist who declined to execute an offered Physician Employment Agreement, communicated that he was unwilling to discuss it during a three-month medical staff leave for “physician burnout,” and did not respond to multiple outreach attempts. CHIC granted his requested leave but treated his failure to sign the offer as a rejection of the offer and withdrew the offer. Peddada sought eight-figure damages based on claims of Americans with Disabilities Act (“ADA”) and Rehabilitation Act disability discrimination, failure to accommodate and retaliation, among others.
Following strategic discovery, the district court granted Hall Render’s summary judgment motion and found that Peddada failed to submit sufficient evidence that he was disabled. The court also concluded that Peddada’s refusal to communicate was a legitimate non-discriminatory reason for CHIC to withdraw the offer of employment.
The court found that Peddada did not proffer prima facie evidence showing substantial impairment of a major life activity for the following reasons:
- Sleeping: An expert’s statement that Peddada’s sleep “may not have been as restful as usual,” and Peddada’s testimony that he often did not want to get up to attend a morning meeting, did not show substantial impairment.
- Thinking, concentrating, communicating and interacting with others: Peddada and his expert did not claim these functions were impaired compared with most people in the general population or outside of work but focused only on impairment in his specific job.
- Work: A person is substantially limited in working only if significantly restricted from performing a class of jobs or a broad range of jobs in various classes as compared to the average person having comparable training, skills and abilities.
- Regarded as Disabled: A perceived impairment is not disabling under the regarded-as prong if it is transitory and minor, meaning it has an actual or expected duration of six months or less.
A & A Appliance Case
By contrast, in Equal Emp. Opportunity Comm’n v. A & A Appliance, Inc., No. 25-1451, 2026 WL 3369889 (10th Cir. Nov. 6, 2026), the Tenth Circuit concluded that information provided to the employer of an unspecified gastrointestinal condition experienced at the end of an employee’s FMLA leave for Covid-19 symptoms raised a genuine issue of fact about whether the employee was disabled and whether the employer should have engaged in an interactive process. After the employee’s discharge, endoscopy results revealed mild but chronic gastritis with “no serious pathology.” The condition was resolved within about two weeks by the employee taking an over-the-counter medication (Opremazole).
The Tenth Circuit indicated that employee communications referencing only generalized ailments, such as “head … really hurting” or “fever and other symptoms” or simply being “sick” are insufficient to notify the employer of a disability because such symptoms are consistent with many short-term, nondisabling ailments, including a common cold. Although clearly a close call, the court found the employee’s notice of a gastric disorder was sufficient because she “connected her various symptoms together, suggesting she had an ongoing illness, even if some of her symptoms were intermittent and inactive at times.” The court pointed out that an impairment that is episodic or in remission is a disability if it would substantially limit a major life activity when active.
Taken together, these two cases help clarify the boundaries of the ADA’s disability definition—a condition that substantially impairs a major life activity—and the employer’s obligations when a medical condition is unclear.
Key Employer Takeaways
- Notice of Disability to Employer
Employer clairvoyance is not required. Unless the disability is obvious, the employee must inform the employer of the disability before the employer can be held liable for failing to accommodate. An employee need not provide a formal diagnosis, the name of the disabling condition or use the word “disabled” to put an employer on notice.
- Reasonable Accommodation Request
A request need not be in writing or formally invoke the words “reasonable accommodation,” but it must make clear that the employee wants assistance for his or her disability. To be reasonable, a leave request must not be indefinite but instead must inform the employer of the expected duration of the impairment, not merely the duration of the leave request itself. In chronic impairment cases, an estimate of when symptoms will subside and allow return to work is probably sufficient.
- Interactive Process
Once an employee provides enough information about his or her limitations and desires to suggest at least the possibility that reasonable accommodation may be found, both parties have an obligation to proceed in a reasonably interactive manner to determine if the employee could be reasonably accommodated. Where notice is ambiguous but sufficient to notify the employer that the employee may have a disability requiring accommodation, the employer must ask for clarification.
- Burnout/Work-Related Stress
The Peddada ruling should not be construed as a conclusion that professional burnout can never constitute a disability. Rather, a temporary inability to work caused by acute work-related stress, without evidence of a long-term or substantial impairment of a major life activity, does not qualify as a disability. Employers should not automatically dismiss a request for leave or accommodation for “burnout” or work-related stress, but engage in the interactive process to obtain clarification as needed.
If you have questions or would like more information about this topic, please contact:
- Brian Sabey at (720) 282-2025 or bsabey@hallrender.com;
- Mark Sabey at (303) 801-3538 or marksabey@hallrender.com;
- Lindsay McManus at (303) 802-1293 or lmcmanus@hallrender.com; or
- Your primary Hall Render contact.
Hall Render blog posts and articles are intended for informational purposes only. For ethical reasons, Hall Render attorneys cannot—outside of an attorney-client relationship—answer specific questions that would be legal advice.